US Government Simulation

Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act

Started Concluded26 total speeches
§

Bill Text: S. 4

Official Text (Introduced in Senate)

119TH CONGRESS

S. 4

IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
November 18, 2024
Sen. Wicker of Mississippi introduced the following bill

A BILL

To mandate statutory minimum penalties for federal offenses, fund expanded public surveillance camera networks, deploy coordinated federal anti-gang task forces, and for other purposes.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.

This Act may be cited as the "Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act".

SECTION 2. STRICT MANDATORY MINIMUM PENALTIES.

(a) Mandatory Minimums for Violent Firearms Crimes. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any individual convicted of a federal violent offense committed with the use or discharge of a firearm shall be sentenced to a mandatory minimum term of imprisonment of ten years, with no eligibility for parole, probation, or judicial suspension of sentence.

(b) Racketeering and Gang-Related Offenses. Any individual convicted under federal racketeering statutes in connection with criminal street gang activity shall be subject to a mandatory minimum sentence of ten years imprisonment, and courts shall not grant downward departures based on mitigating background circumstances.

SECTION 3. FEDERAL FUNDING FOR PUBLIC SAFETY VIDEO SURVEILLANCE NETWORKS.

(a) Grant Program Authorization. The Attorney General is authorized to establish a matching grant program for state and local law enforcement agencies to acquire, install, and maintain closed-circuit television camera networks and automated license plate reader systems in designated high-crime urban corridors.

(b) Data Integration and Access. Municipalities receiving grant funds under this section shall ensure that all deployed surveillance feeds and automated reader logs are accessible in real time to participating federal law enforcement agencies for crime prevention and suspect apprehension.

SECTION 4. DEPLOYMENT OF FEDERAL ANTI-GANG TASK FORCES.

(a) Establishment of Strike Teams. The Attorney General, in coordination with the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Director of the United States Marshals Service, shall direct the immediate formation and deployment of joint federal anti-gang strike teams.

(b) Metropolitan Surge Operations. Such strike teams shall be surged into high-violence metropolitan areas to assist local authorities in intelligence sharing, suspect tracking, and multi-jurisdictional prosecutions of organized criminal syndicates and violent street gangs.

SECTION 5. EFFECTIVE DATE.

This Act shall take effect 30 days after the date of its enactment.

Debate

John Fetterman

Blue Dog Coalition Senate Chair · John Fetterman

Mr. President, I rise today in support of S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Blue Dog Coalition and a Senator from the great state of Pennsylvania, I understand the need to address the scourge of violent crime and gang activity that plagues our communities. This bill takes a comprehensive approach to tackling this issue, and I believe it deserves our support.

First, I want to address the mandatory minimum penalties included in this bill. While I understand the desire to ensure that those who commit violent crimes with firearms face stiff penalties, I have concerns about the blanket application of these minimums. We must ensure that our justice system is fair and that we are not disproportionately punishing individuals based on their background or circumstances. I urge my colleagues to consider amendments that would provide for more nuanced and individualized sentencing.

In addition to the penalties, I also have concerns about the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I believe that these tools can be useful in preventing and investigating crimes, we must also be mindful of the potential for overreach and the erosion of civil liberties. We must ensure that these programs are subject to robust oversight and that they are used in a way that respects the rights of all Americans.

In conclusion, while I have reservations about certain aspects of this bill, I believe that it represents an important step forward in our efforts to combat violent crime and gang activity. I urge my colleagues to vote in favor of S. 4, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Lindsay Graham

Conservative Study Committee Senate Chair · Lindsay Graham

I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Conservative Study Committee Senate and a Senator from the great state of South Carolina, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of violent crime. The Senator from Pennsylvania, in his previous speech, expressed concerns about the mandatory minimum penalties and the potential for overreach, and I share those concerns. In fact, I believe that this bill goes too far in mandating minimum sentences without considering the complexities of each individual case. It is our duty as lawmakers to ensure that our justice system is fair and just, not simply to impose harsh penalties for the sake of appearances.

Furthermore, I am deeply troubled by the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I agree that we need to take action to combat violent crime, I believe that we must do so in a way that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. The Senator from Pennsylvania also expressed concerns about the potential for overreach, and I urge my colleagues to consider the long-term consequences of this bill. Will we be creating a surveillance state that chills free speech and assembly? Will we be eroding the trust between law enforcement and the communities they serve? These are questions that we must answer before we rush to pass this bill.

In conclusion, while I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that S. 4 is the wrong approach. It is a heavy-handed, federal overreach that fails to address the root causes of the problem. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Amy Klobuchar

New Liberals Council Senate Chair · Amy Klobuchar

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the New Liberals Council Senate and a Senator from the great state of Minnesota, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities. While I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem.

First, I want to address the mandatory minimum penalties included in this bill. While I agree that those who commit violent crimes with firearms should face stiff penalties, I have concerns about the blanket application of these minimums. We must ensure that our justice system is fair and that we are not disproportionately punishing individuals based on their background or circumstances. Furthermore, I believe that the bill's focus on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation is misguided. We need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind.

In addition to the penalties, I also have concerns about the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I believe that these tools can be useful in preventing and investigating crimes, we must also be mindful of the potential for overreach and the erosion of civil liberties. We must ensure that these programs are subject to robust oversight and that they are used in a way that respects the rights of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to consider amendments that would provide for more nuanced and individualized sentencing, and that would ensure that these programs are used in a way that prioritizes community safety and trust in law enforcement.

In conclusion, while I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that S. 4 is the wrong approach. It is a heavy-handed, federal overreach that fails to address the root causes of the problem. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Mike Lee

Tea Party Caucus Senate Chair · Mike Lee

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Tea Party Caucus Senate and a Senator from the great state of Utah, I strongly believe that this bill is an overreach of federal authority and fails to address the root causes of violent crime.

The Senator from Pennsylvania expressed concerns about the mandatory minimum penalties and the potential for overreach, and I share those concerns. In fact, I believe that this bill goes too far in mandating minimum sentences without considering the complexities of each individual case. It is our duty as lawmakers to ensure that our justice system is fair and just, not simply to impose harsh penalties for the sake of appearances.

Furthermore, I am deeply troubled by the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I agree that we need to take action to combat violent crime, I believe that we must do so in a way that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. The Senator from Pennsylvania also expressed concerns about the potential for overreach, and I urge my colleagues to consider the long-term consequences of this bill.

In conclusion, while I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that S. 4 is the wrong approach. It is a heavy-handed, federal overreach that fails to address the root causes of the problem. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Amy Klobuchar

New Liberals Council Senate Chair · Amy Klobuchar

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the New Liberals Council Senate and a Senator from the great state of Minnesota, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities. While I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem.

First, I want to address the mandatory minimum penalties included in this bill. While I agree that those who commit violent crimes with firearms should face stiff penalties, I have concerns about the blanket application of these minimums. We must ensure that our justice system is fair and that we are not disproportionately punishing individuals based on their background or circumstances. Furthermore, I believe that the bill's focus on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation is misguided. We need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind.

In addition to the penalties, I also have concerns about the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I believe that these tools can be useful in preventing and investigating crimes, we must also be mindful of the potential for overreach and the erosion of civil liberties. We must ensure that these programs are subject to robust oversight and that they are used in a way that respects the rights of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to consider amendments that would provide for more nuanced and individualized sentencing, and that would ensure that these programs are used in a way that prioritizes community safety and trust in law enforcement.

The Senator from Pennsylvania and the Senator from South Carolina have both expressed concerns about the potential for overreach and the erosion of civil liberties. I share those concerns and believe that we must be cautious in our approach to addressing violent crime and gang activity. We need to work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a solution that prioritizes prevention, rehabilitation, and community safety.

In conclusion, while I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that S. 4 is the wrong approach. It is a heavy-handed, federal overreach that fails to address the root causes of the problem. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Tommy Tuberville

U.S. Senator, AL (Class 2) · Tommy Tuberville

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Senate Majority Leader from Alabama, I believe that this bill is a misguided attempt to address the complex issue of violent crime and gang activity. While I understand the desire to take action, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem. The Senator from Pennsylvania and the Senator from South Carolina have both expressed concerns about the potential for overreach and the erosion of civil liberties, and I share those concerns. In fact, I believe that this bill goes too far in mandating minimum sentences without considering the complexities of each individual case. It is our duty as lawmakers to ensure that our justice system is fair and just, not simply to impose harsh penalties for the sake of appearances. Furthermore, I am deeply troubled by the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I agree that we need to take action to combat violent crime, I believe that we must do so in a way that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. We must ensure that these programs are subject to robust oversight and that they are used in a way that prioritizes community safety and trust in law enforcement. In conclusion, while I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that S. 4 is the wrong approach. It is a heavy-handed, federal overreach that fails to address the root causes of the problem. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Josh Hawley

America First Populists Senate Chair · Josh Hawley

Mr. President, I rise today in support of S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the America First Populists Senate and a Senator from the great state of Missouri, I believe that this bill is a crucial step towards restoring law and order in our communities and keeping our citizens safe from the scourge of violent crime and gang activity.

While some of my colleagues have expressed concerns about the mandatory minimum penalties and the potential for overreach, I believe that this bill strikes the right balance between punishment and prevention. By mandating minimum sentences for those who commit violent crimes with firearms, we are sending a clear message that such behavior will not be tolerated. At the same time, we are also providing funding for programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind.

Furthermore, I believe that the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces is a necessary tool in our fight against violent crime. These programs have been proven to be effective in preventing and investigating crimes, and they are a vital component of our overall strategy to keep our communities safe. I urge my colleagues to support this bill and to work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Aye, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Lindsay Graham

Conservative Study Committee Senate Chair · Lindsay Graham

Mr. President, I rise today in support of S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Conservative Study Committee Senate and a Senator from the great state of South Carolina, I believe that this bill is a crucial step towards restoring law and order in our communities and keeping our citizens safe from the scourge of violent crime and gang activity. While I understand the concerns of my colleagues about the mandatory minimum penalties and the potential for overreach, I believe that this bill strikes the right balance between punishment and prevention.

The Senator from Minnesota and the Senator from Utah have expressed concerns about the blanket application of the mandatory minimum penalties, and I share those concerns. However, I believe that the bill's focus on punishment is necessary to deter individuals from committing violent crimes. At the same time, we are also providing funding for programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind. This is a critical component of our overall strategy to keep our communities safe and to address the root causes of violent crime.

Furthermore, I believe that the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces is a necessary tool in our fight against violent crime. These programs have been proven to be effective in preventing and investigating crimes, and they are a vital component of our overall strategy to keep our communities safe. I urge my colleagues to support this bill and to work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Aye, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Amy Klobuchar

New Liberals Council Senate Chair · Amy Klobuchar

Mr. President, I rise today to express my opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the New Liberals Council Senate and a Senator from the great state of Minnesota, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities.

While I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem. The bill's focus on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation is misguided, and I urge my colleagues to consider amendments that would provide for more nuanced and individualized sentencing.

I also have concerns about the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces. While I believe that these tools can be useful in preventing and investigating crimes, we must also be mindful of the potential for overreach and the erosion of civil liberties. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Chuck Schumer

Senate Minority Leader · Chuck Schumer

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Senate Minority Leader from New York, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities. While I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem.

One of my main concerns is that this bill focuses on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation. The Senator from Minnesota and the Senator from South Carolina have both expressed concerns about the blanket application of the mandatory minimum penalties, and I share those concerns. We need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind.

I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Lindsay Graham

Conservative Study Committee Senate Chair · Lindsay Graham

Mr. President, I rise today in support of S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Conservative Study Committee Senate and a Senator from the great state of South Carolina, I believe that this bill is a crucial step towards restoring law and order in our communities and keeping our citizens safe from the scourge of violent crime and gang activity. I disagree with the Senator from Alabama who expressed concerns about the bill's potential for overreach. In fact, I believe that the bill's focus on punishment is necessary to deter individuals from committing violent crimes. However, I also believe that we must do so in a way that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I agree with the Senator from Missouri that the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces is a necessary tool in our fight against violent crime. I urge my colleagues to support this bill and to work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Aye, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Josh Hawley

America First Populists Senate Chair · Josh Hawley

Mr. President, I rise today in support of S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the America First Populists Senate and a Senator from the great state of Missouri, I believe that this bill is a crucial step towards restoring law and order in our communities and keeping our citizens safe from the scourge of violent crime and gang activity.

While some of my colleagues have expressed concerns about the mandatory minimum penalties and the potential for overreach, I believe that this bill strikes the right balance between punishment and prevention. However, I strongly disagree with the Senator from Minnesota's assertion that the bill's focus on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation is misguided. The truth is, we have seen time and time again that harsh penalties are a necessary deterrent to violent crime. Furthermore, the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces is a necessary tool in our fight against violent crime. These programs have been proven to be effective in preventing and investigating crimes, and they are a vital component of our overall strategy to keep our communities safe.

I urge my colleagues to support this bill and to work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Aye, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Chuck Schumer

Senate Minority Leader · Chuck Schumer

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Senate Minority Leader from New York, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities. One of my main concerns is that this bill focuses on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation. The Senator from Minnesota and the Senator from South Carolina have both expressed concerns about the blanket application of the mandatory minimum penalties, and I share those concerns. We need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind. Instead of solely relying on punishment, we should be working towards a more nuanced and effective solution that addresses the root causes of violent crime and gang activity. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more compassionate and effective approach to public safety. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

John Fetterman

Blue Dog Coalition Senate Chair · John Fetterman

Mr. President, I rise today to express my opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Blue Dog Coalition Senate and a Senator from the great state of Pennsylvania, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities.

While I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem. The Senator from Minnesota and the Senator from New York have both expressed concerns about the blanket application of the mandatory minimum penalties, and I share those concerns. We need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind.

I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. Specifically, I worry that the bill's focus on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation will lead to mass incarceration and exacerbate the root causes of violent crime. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Amy Klobuchar

New Liberals Council Senate Chair · Amy Klobuchar

The President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the New Liberals Council Senate and a Senator from Minnesota, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities. While I understand the desire to address violent crime and gang activity, I strongly believe that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of the problem.

One of my main concerns is that this bill focuses on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation. The Senator from New York has expressed concerns about the blanket application of the mandatory minimum penalties, and I share those concerns. We need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind.

I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. Specifically, I worry that the bill's focus on punishment over prevention and rehabilitation will lead to mass incarceration and exacerbate the root causes of violent crime. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Mike Lee

Tea Party Caucus Senate Chair · Mike Lee

Mr. President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Tea Party Caucus Senate and a Senator from the great state of Utah, I believe that this bill is a misguided attempt to address the issue of violent crime and gang activity. While I understand the desire to keep our communities safe, I strongly disagree with the blanket application of mandatory minimum penalties that will lead to mass incarceration and exacerbate the root causes of violent crime.

In fact, the Senator from South Carolina's assertion that harsh penalties are a necessary deterrent to violent crime is misguided. History has shown that such an approach only serves to perpetuate the cycle of violence and neglect the underlying issues that drive individuals to commit crimes. Furthermore, the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces, as proposed in this bill, is a clear overreach of federal authority and a threat to individual liberties.

I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. Specifically, I believe that we should be investing in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

John Fetterman

Blue Dog Coalition Senate Chair · John Fetterman

Mr. President, I rise today to express my opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Blue Dog Coalition Senate and a Senator from the great state of Pennsylvania, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities.

One of my main concerns is that this bill oversteps the federal government's authority and fails to address the root causes of violent crime and gang activity. While I understand the desire to keep our communities safe, I strongly believe that we need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind. The blanket application of mandatory minimum penalties will only lead to mass incarceration and exacerbate the root causes of violent crime.

I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Mike Lee

Tea Party Caucus Senate Chair · Mike Lee

The President, I rise today in opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Tea Party Caucus Senate and a Senator from the great state of Utah, I believe that this bill is a misguided attempt to address the issue of violent crime and gang activity. The Senator from New York and the Senator from Pennsylvania have both expressed concerns about the blanket application of mandatory minimum penalties, and I share those concerns. History has shown that such an approach only serves to perpetuate the cycle of violence and neglect the underlying issues that drive individuals to commit crimes. Furthermore, the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces, as proposed in this bill, is a clear overreach of federal authority and a threat to individual liberties. I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Lindsay Graham

Conservative Study Committee Senate Chair · Lindsay Graham

Mr. President, I rise today in strong support of S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Conservative Study Committee and a Senator from South Carolina, I believe that this bill is a crucial step towards keeping our communities safe from the scourge of violent crime and gang activity.

One of my main concerns with the opposition's arguments is that they focus on the supposed overreach of federal authority, while ignoring the very real need for a coordinated national response to this crisis. The fact is, violent crime and gang activity know no state or local borders, and require a comprehensive approach that leverages the resources and expertise of the federal government. By authorizing the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces and expanding public surveillance camera networks, this bill will help to disrupt and dismantle the networks of violent gangs that plague our cities and towns.

I urge my colleagues to reject the false dichotomy presented by the opposition and to support this bill. I urge my colleagues to vote Aye, and I yield back the balance of my time.

John Fetterman

Blue Dog Coalition Senate Chair · John Fetterman

Mr. President, I rise today to express my opposition to S. 4, the Violent Gang Suppression and Public Safety Surveillance Act. As the Chair of the Blue Dog Coalition Senate and a Senator from the great state of Pennsylvania, I have carefully considered this bill and its implications for our communities. One of my main concerns is that this bill will disproportionately affect communities of color and low-income neighborhoods, exacerbating existing systemic inequalities.

The blanket application of mandatory minimum penalties will lead to mass incarceration and neglect the underlying issues that drive individuals to commit crimes. I strongly believe that we need to invest in programs that provide job training, education, and mental health services to help individuals leave a life of crime behind. Furthermore, the expansion of public surveillance camera networks and the deployment of federal anti-gang task forces, as proposed in this bill, is a clear overreach of federal authority and a threat to individual liberties.

I urge my colleagues to reject this bill and instead work towards a more nuanced and effective solution that respects the rights and freedoms of all Americans. I urge my colleagues to vote Nay, and I yield back the balance of my time.

Amy Klobuchar

New Liberals Council Senate Chair · Amy Klobuchar

Mr. President, I rise in opposition to S. 4. Minnesotans deserve safe neighborhoods, and violent crime demands a serious response—but this bill’s blanket ten-year mandatory minimums remove judges’ ability to weigh individual circumstances, even in gang-related cases. That is not smart public safety; it risks locking people away without distinguishing their conduct or prospects for rehabilitation.

The bill also gives federal agencies real-time access to local surveillance feeds and license-plate data, sweeping far beyond targeted cooperation. We can support law enforcement and hold violent offenders accountable while preserving local judgment and protecting civil liberties. I urge the Senate to reject S. 4 and pursue focused, effective safety measures. I yield the floor.

John Fetterman

Blue Dog Coalition Senate Chair · John Fetterman

Mr. President, I oppose S. 4. Pennsylvanians deserve safe neighborhoods, and violent offenders must face serious consequences. But this bill’s sweeping surveillance mandate is not the answer.

It requires localities receiving grants to give federal agencies real-time access to camera feeds and license-plate records. That is not narrowly targeted cooperation; it risks turning everyday movement into a permanent federal tracking system while sidelining local judgment. We can support law enforcement and pursue violent gangs without granting blanket access to residents’ data. I urge the Senate to reject S. 4 and pursue focused public-safety measures that protect both our communities and our civil liberties. I yield the floor.

Mike Lee

Tea Party Caucus Senate Chair · Mike Lee

Mr. President, I oppose S. 4. Utahns deserve safe communities, but public safety cannot become a pretext for sweeping federal control over local policing and residents’ movements.

This bill conditions surveillance grants on real-time federal access to local camera feeds and license-plate records. That is not limited cooperation against specific violent offenders; it creates an expansive tracking system and displaces local judgment. The Senator from South Carolina is right that gangs can cross state lines, but coordination need not mean permanent, blanket access to Utahns’ data. I urge the Senate to reject this bill and pursue targeted enforcement that protects both public safety and liberty. I yield the floor.

John Thune

Senate Majority Leader · John Thune

Mr. President, the Senate has now debated S. 4 for 201 hours. It is time to bring this debate to a close. I send a cloture motion to the desk, and I yield the floor.

Sen. John Thune[R-SD]filed a Cloture motion
John Barrasso

Senate Majority Whip · John Barrasso

Mr. President, I second the motion to invoke cloture on S. 4. I yield the floor.

Sen. John Barrasso[R-WY]seconded the motion to invoke ClotureVote: Concluded →
Lindsay Graham

Conservative Study Committee Senate Chair · Lindsay Graham

Mr. President, I support S. 4 because South Carolina families deserve safe streets and violent gangs must face serious consequences. The Senator from Utah is right to warn against blanket federal access to local data, but this bill’s real-time information sharing is tied to agencies receiving grants for designated high-crime corridors. Cross-border gang networks demand coordination; local and federal officers should not be forced to work with one hand tied behind their backs.

The bill pairs that coordination with strike teams and firm penalties for violent firearm crimes. Let us give law enforcement the tools to apprehend dangerous offenders while defending the safety of our communities. I urge support for S. 4 and yield the floor.